Comparison

Starbucks Sumatra Coffee vs Kicking Horse Coffee Kick Ass

Two pods that land close together on paper: same roast level, also from Indonesia and shares earthy. Side by side, from each roaster's own listing.

Sumatra CoffeeKick Ass
RoasterStarbucksKicking Horse Coffee
FormatK-CupK-Cup
RoastDarkDark
OriginIndonesiaIndonesia
Tasting notesearthydark chocolate, molasses, licorice, earthy
CaffeineRegularRegular
CertificationsKosherUSDA Organic, Fair Trade
Typical price$$$$$
Starbucks

Sumatra Coffee

For K-Cup machines, 22 pods to a pack. Dark roast Indonesian, with one note: earthy. Kosher, not flavored. If you know you like deep, earthy cups, this is your lane; if you want fruit, look elsewhere.

Best for K-Cup owners who like dark, earthy coffee

See Sumatra Coffee →
Kicking Horse Coffee

Kick Ass

The Kick Ass dark roast in K-Cup form: dark chocolate, molasses, licorice and earthy notes, from Indonesian coffee. It's organic and fair trade, licensed for the pod, and comes 20 to a box. Bold and low on brightness, going by the list.

Pick it if dark chocolate, molasses and licorice sound good to you; organic matters to you.

Best for K-Cup owners who want a dark, earthy organic pod

See Kick Ass →

Built from each roaster's own product listing and our takes. We haven't tasted these side by side; see how we research.